How About M?
Well, judging has finally completed. The winners are below, but before you go and look at the chart, please remember: All of these games were great. I had a lot of fun judging for this competition and hope to see compos of similar quality in the future.
So thanks to everyone! You're all awesome.
Now, without further ado, your rankings
18 pts: Mademoiselle
15 pts: Dial 'M' for MacGuffin
9 pts: Monster Magnet Meow
7 pts: Marble Massacre
7 pts: Mason's Memoirs: The Middle Months
7 pts: Wind (with a capital M)
As you can see the judges had some thoughts in line with each other but we each had different favourites and ideas about what was better or worse.
The way that we decided the results were that each of the three judges came up with their own criteria and then ranked each game within their own system. Then, I took the rankings and gave out points: 6 points for first place, 5 for second, etc. etc. Adding the points up we got overall rankings.
In any case, I will be posting full reviews from each judge in the posts that follow. Congratulations to CrazyAznGamer, and congratulations to everyone who participated!